ResellerRatings
Store Ratings Best/Worst Stores Stores by Category Top reviewers FAQs
For Companies

Full Rating Profile + -

Product & services pricing
4.11/5
Chance of future purchase:
4.50/5
Shipping & packaging:
4.44/5
Customer service:
4.50/5
Return/Replacement policy:
4.27/5

Verified
5/5

2023-10-22

Great delivery time!

"Everything positive! Recommend to everyone!"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

Verified
5/5

2023-10-22

Great8

"The fish was perfectly frozen. Shipped quickly with no problems and the fish is fresh!"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

Verified
5/5

2021-11-28

My annual gift to self!

"Of course shipping fish from PA to Florida is a pricey proposition, but I can't help but order Bluefish once a year. When we lived in Brooklyn, we'd buy whole blue fish fresh off the boat at Sheepshead Bay for 25 cents and for another 25 cents take it across the street from the dock where we'd get it filleted! A lot has changed in 50 years so treating ourselves to this taste of yesteryear is well worth it. Kudos to the freshness of the fish from Wholey's. Smelled as though caught the same day. Defrosted overnight in refrigerator. Pan fried with onions and seasonings. Nothing fancy. Delicious!"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process

Verified
4/5

2023-10-19

Why Shipping Fee

"I was never charged a shipping fee before. I am very disappointed."


Verified
5/5

2023-10-06

Quality can't be beat!

"There lobster tails and jumbo raw shrimp are top quality!"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

Verified
5/5

2023-10-11

"Haven't ordered since we relocated from the left coast, but my experiences with Wholey's have always been great!"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases

Verified
4/5

2023-10-11

Max cooks

"First time user. I use these to make homemade soup."


Verified
5/5

2023-10-04

Great fish

"I am a returning customer. I enjoy black bass and I am glad that I can get my order shipped. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases

Verified
4/5

2023-09-26

First Time Catch

"I was very surprised Wholey's deliver and the selection for the fish products were great!!!"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

Verified
4/5

2023-09-26

"It would just be nice to receive a coupon occasionally to show your appreciation for our business. What we purchase is never on sale. Shipping seems a little steep also. You pay almost as much for shipping as you do the product if you don't spend $200 on your order. "


Verified
5/5

2023-09-20

Pickled

"I was looking for pickled herring that was not filet and found Wholey's while googling for the herring. Questioned if the herring was whole and got a response in a short time. Great seervice."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Overall customer service

Verified
5/5

2023-09-20

Beef bacon lover

"Will find out if this product is any good. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases

Verified
5/5

2023-09-12

Great food great ordering experience

"It was easy to find what we wanted and more. The order process was quick and easy."


Verified
1/5

2023-09-03

Please Fix This!

"I’ve spent a LOT of money at Wholey’s in recent years. So, AFTER I’ve checked out apparently, you ask if I want any of the following items (whatever they may be). If I choose an addition few items, you THEN create a new order and want to charge me shipping. This is AFTER the fact I’ve already spent a few hundred dollars. This continues to happen. You’re about to lose me as a customer. There are other seafood companies out there offering the same as you. Do better. Especially for returning customers. This May very well be my last order. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases

Verified
5/5

2023-09-03

Quick and smooth purchase

"This is the first time I am purchasing from wholey. My experience was overall good, however, price was a little bit on the higher side."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases