ResellerRatings
Store Ratings Best/Worst Stores Stores by Category Top reviewers FAQs
For Companies

Full Rating Profile + -

Product & services pricing
3.75/5
Chance of future purchase:
2.82/5
Shipping & packaging:
2.50/5
Customer service:
3.75/5
Return/Replacement policy:
0.00/5

Verified
4/5

2017-08-24

Great website, good quality, slow shipping time. Overall my go to for all card sleeves needs.

"The ability to buy card sets by game is amazing and extremely handy for a newcomer like me who doesn't want to risk getting wrong sleeves. The option to choose between regular and premium is also great. The premium quality sleeves are excellent. Only downside to the whole experience was the slow processing for shipment. My order shipped a week after the purchase."


Verified
5/5

2017-08-21

Great!

"I found everything that I was looking for, simple page and great product"


Verified
5/5

2017-08-20

Perfect

"Easy To use
Good quality
Fast shipping
"


Verified
5/5

2017-08-17

Card Protectors At It AGAIN

"Transaction was smooth for a quick purchase to the product. Love the card sleeves bought a bundle to weed out inconsistency ."


Verified
5/5

2017-08-17

Cheap and easy

"Super cheap compared to other stores and easy to find card sleeves that fit my munchkin cards. "


Verified
5/5

2017-08-14

a catchy title

"I had been looking for reasonably priced, quality, clear card sleeves for my growing board game collection. I had seen mayday sleeves mentioned a few times on sides like BGG ( along with other sleeves like FFG, and ultra pro). Competitor sleeves tended to be twice the price, or with matte finishes/designs that didn't suit my needs . Normally I'd buy board game products at a site like cool stuff inc, but they didn't have your sleeves in stock, so when I had need of enough sleeves to warrant an order here I am.

As for the actual site, it seems simple, uncluttered, and the spread sheet listed the appropriate sleeve for the games in my collection ( except for yet to be released kickstarter games which is reasonable). Maybe a spread sheet isn't the most user friendly thing in the world but there were options like an app if ctrl+ f was too difficult for me.

The only remaining question is, "Are the sleeves as advertised?". I'm reasonably confident based on the feedback I've seen elsewhere, but one never knows. And I might prefer one thickness of sleeve over another after handling them
"


Verified
5/5

2017-08-14

The right sleeves

"Found the perfect sized sleeves for a game that I had been looking for, for awhile. They had "built custom sleeves" for it. Love mayday games!"


Verified
5/5

2017-08-13

Thank you!

"Found everything i needed in one place, Thanks!"


Verified
5/5

2017-08-11

Protection for my Cards !

"Now my cards are safe from the sticky fingers of the kids who play with them..."


Verified
5/5

2017-08-11

":-) "


Verified
5/5

2017-08-09

Too Easy and Inexpensive NOT to

"Pricing and shipping very competitive. I sleeve my cards after the destruction of my original Catan deck. Any card heavy game, you better protect them!"


Verified
5/5

2017-08-05

Simplycity is the game

"A list of games and what sleeve + quantity... Pricless! Easy to find what you need. Made a huge order for all my games :)
Price is ok - lets hope that quality will be good...
"


Verified
4/5

2017-08-05

Reliable

"It was easy, but a little drawn out and kind of tedious "


Verified
4/5

2017-08-04

lack of stock

"Missing sleeves I need that are not in stock."


Verified
5/5

2017-08-04

Quick, Plainless Checkout

"You have theist combination of quality sleeves (the premium sleeves) and price on the market"