"Great experience buying directly from Mayday games--better prices than other online retailers and the processing/shipping is blindingly fast. Very happy with Mayday Games."
"A flawless experience, I really love the elegant design. beautiful."
"Amazing response time! I was pleasantly surprised by the near instantaneous feedback and response despite emailing my question at midnight."
"Had a great experience from Mayday games. They don't feel like an evil corporate entity I've sold my soul to. I could have a beer with these people and play some dexterity games with disastrous consequences. 5/7 will order from again."
"My wife and I order some card sleeves from Mayday Games a few weeks ago for our game of 7 Wonders. After a while of being frustrated for how long it was taking to deliver someone from their support team emailed me letting me know that the sleeves weren't delivered because the address provided was non-existant. Turns out that I had put in a wrong address because we had just moved shortly before we ordered the sleeves. Once I provided them with the correct address the sleeves arrived in two business days and they are great!"
"I ordered a number of sleeves in December and chose international package shipping, which indicated an expected delivery time of 7-21 business days (a max of just over 4 weeks).
After something like 12 weeks elapsed, and after a posting here after 9 weeks, customer service resent the order and it arrived in about a week.
I have updated my original 2 star rating to 3 stars due to this, but when I look at the website, it still allows the choice of shipment with an expectation of 7 to 21 business days for shipping to Canada, which their service people have stated to me is not a delivery time they will honor (they pointed me to some terms of shipment which are apparently in their FAQ, but not clearly stated on their check out page.)
If the terms and expectations for shipment were clearly stated, I would likely update my rating to a 4 at this point. However, I remain disappointed by the overall experience.
"
"I didn't know which size my cards were going to be so I sent an support request to Mayday Games. They got back to me within a day and linked me to all the supported sleeves for my cards. Thanks! "
"Very happy with my purchase. These are not the high end premium card sleeves, but they also are not penny sleeves. The multiple sizes that Mayday provides means you get a pretty snug fit. I can stack my cards, shuffle them, and play with them, all very comfortably. If you want a sleeve that works and feels nice enough, without breaking the bank, these are right in that sweet spot."
"I'm just not sure about the shipping method, the first one mentionned sleeves ?
Love that I have a Messenger conversation openend as soon as the order is placed.
Can't wait to receive it and get some dead man drawing ;)"
"I really enjoy the Mayday sleeves. I know they are a little bit cheaper than some of the other sleeves (Dragon Shield and FFG), but for the price, these sleeves are great quality.
I use the Penny sleeves as well as the premium sleeves for many of my games. I will continue to buy Mayday games sleeves for all of my games."
"I do a lot of print-and-play games, so card sleeves are necessary to make the games last. Mayday has the right product for me every time. I'm happy to say that my games have lasted through hours and hours of use thanks to Mayday card sleeves."
"One of my friends is looking to sleeve one of his games which requires the 63.5x88mm size. He hasn't ever sleeved any of his games before and I was telling him that I have had great experience with Mayday quality. He wants to use premium thickness sleeves though and when I went to add them to the order they weren't available. Hopefully next time they will be, of course he may end up going with a different provider in the meantime."
"Very smooth experience overall"
"An issue while ordering generated 3 separate orders for the same items. I sent Mayday an email and it was immediately resolved the next day. Jeremy was a big help."
"No problems! Easy purchasing process."