Elite seals are prestigious banners given to retailers who are loved by their customers. To get one, a retailer has to consistently get high scores over time
5 / 5 (1 reviews) average score over the past This merchant had 100% positive reviews over the last Six Months
Six Months
Positive: 1
Neutral: 0
Negative: 0
Write a Review
Customer Reviews | Filter Reviews
5/5
2025-01-02
Ace
"been with this company for years. Mark is honest, knowledgeable, will always do business with him."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
5/5
2023-08-30
You can buy with confidence at MR!
"I've been buying from Mark at Montana Rarities for almost 4 years. I was initially hesitant to make any substantial purchases from a stranger online. So...I just started ordering low value items on the website (kinda tip-toed into it) and slowly went up until I felt comfortable enough to order higher dollar items. Mark has never disappointed. You get what you order in a timely manner and the package is very discreet so postal workers don't know what is in the box. He lets you pay by personal check and then ships the goods as soon as it clears. Montana Rarities is not one of these big clearinghouses that buy and sell huge quantities of precious metals. My impression is that it's a "mom-and-pop shop" with a small building and just a few employees. But that's just my impression from seeing the website and dealing with Mark. I could be totally wrong on that."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
5/5
2021-03-23
Bullion order March 2021
"Mark has a great selection of unique pieces with competitive pricing. His customer service is excellent with quick, helpful responses. Highly recommend working with Montana Rarities."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
4/5
2017-04-13
Reliable
"Buying precious metals online can be nerve wracking but I get all my silver Maples there and have never had a problem. Old and reliable site."
5/5
2014-01-16
"I was debating whether to write this review or not because I want to keep the best kept secret on the interwebs to myself and close friends and family. I have participated in MT Rarites monthly purchase program for a year now and have been floored at the service and integrity in which they operate. I have not yet found a better price or program that meets my budgetary needs. Any questions I asked were answered quickly and concisely. I can not say enough good things about the crew at MT Rarites. If you are looking for an excellent price, outstanding service, and flexible investing look no further."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
5/5
2013-05-28
"Best place to get your precious metals. If you don't know anything about silver, this is the place to go.I could. send my little old grandma and feel confident in the service Montana rarities provides."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
5/5
2013-02-03
"Just did a transaction with Mark. Very nice guy, and will gladly be doing future business with Montana Rarities. Found him during a website search for Engelhard Prospectors. Am quite pleased at the results of my dealings with him. You will be glad you when you choose Montana Rarities for your precious metal needs."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
5/5
2012-06-19
"There is not a better person than Mark to deal with. He is a 5 Star Seller and goes the extra mile for his customers. Thanks again Mark"
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
5/5
2012-02-28
"I have done business here for almost a year now and I have to say I have yet to see any reason to look elsewhere. The proprietor (Mark) is direct, professional, and prompt with everything he does.
He is easy to work with and will always give you a level and honest response to whatever you inquire about.
Aside from the previously mentioned qualities, I really like the variety of products offered. He has the standard classics along with little known and seldom seen rarities that will make brief appearances before they are scooped up.
Also, he always advertises what he has in stock and I have yet to find him advertising something he does not have physical possession of (unless its noted in the description)."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
5/5
2012-02-22
"Montana Rarities is the best online precious metals vendor I've delt with. Great pricing, FAST shipping and costomer service second to none."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
5/5
2012-02-20
"Mr. Haythornthwaite was extremely responsive, and was very helpful in finding a solution to some difficulties I have in receiving shipments of valuable items."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
5/5
2011-08-05
"I was looking to sell some coins. I was nervous about dealing with a stranger over the internet, but being from a very rural area, the internet is my only option for a lot of things. I decided to take a chance with Montana Rarities because of the 100% positive reviews and I wasn't disappointed.
The entire transaction took eight days. I sent off my initial email inquiry on a Wednesday and received a cashier’s check on Thursday of the following week. Mark was professional, knowledgeable and the prices he offered were much higher that what I’d been expecting.
My only regret is that I don’t have more coins to sell, but if I ever do I will definitely deal with Montana Rarities again."
Detailed Ratings
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
5/5
2011-07-24
"My order was promptly shipped and the product was exactly as described and competitively priced. I will definitely order product from Montana Rarities again in the future."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
5/5
2011-07-20
"My order was easy to place, arrived quickly and was accurate."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
5/5
2011-07-18
"I have had two very pleasant transactions with Montana Rarities. The exchanges were both informative and profitable, so much so, that all my future transactions will begin with this vendor."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
1 - 15 of 38 reviews
Are you this business?
Accelerate your voice by collecting Ratings and Reviews with us! Claim your business page for free or Learn More
Retailer Information
Contact:
9:00am - 5:00pm Mountain Time
406-396-9468
customers@montanararities.com
Montana Rarities
visit the website
Share Montana Rarities's Store Rating
