We have detected that javascript is currently disabled. To get the fullest experience from our site we suggest enabling javascript. If you have any issues using our site please contact us.

e.g. Such as Newegg | browse by category or see best/worst

Stores > Montana Rarities
  • Montana Raritie

    Hundreds of thousands of Shoppers visit ResellerRatings every month to check out real reviews of shopping experiences before they buy!

      9:00am - 5:00pm Mountain Time

    Payment options

    • checkmark icon Visa / Mastercard
    • checkmark icon American Express
    • checkmark icon Discover
    • checkmark icon Money Order
    • option not available COD
    • checkmark icon Check
    • checkmark icon Wire Transfer
    • option not available Apple Pay
    • option not available PayPal

    Shipping options

    • option not available UPS Ground
    • option not available FedEx Ground
    • option not available FedEx Express
    • option not available Priority Next Day
    • option not available Standard Next Day
    • option not available International
    • checkmark icon 2-3 Day Delivery
    • option not available Digital Delivery
    • option not available Amazon Prime

    Online Ordering

    • checkmark icon Online Ordering
    • checkmark icon Online Ordering Tracking
    • checkmark icon Secure Order Processing
    • option not available Require User Registration
    • checkmark icon Guaranteed Security


    • checkmark icon International Order
    • checkmark icon Customer Info. Confidential
    • checkmark icon Customer Support
    • checkmark icon RMA Required
    • checkmark icon Review Guard
    • checkmark icon Notified of Public Replies
  • Review History & Profile See full Rating history

    Product & services pricing 0.00/10
    Chance of future purchase: 0.00/10
    Shipping & packaging: 0.00/10
    Customer service: 0.00/10
    Return/Replacement policy: 0.00/10
Voice your opinion! Review Montana Rarities by clicking a star below.
Rating 8/10


"Buying precious metals online can be nerve wracking but I get all my silver Maples there and have never had a problem. Old and reliable site."

Rating 10/10

"I was debating whether to write this review or not because I want to keep the best kept secret on the interwebs to myself and close friends and family. I have participated in MT Rarites monthly purchase program for a year now and have been floored at the service and integrity in which they operate. I have not yet found a better price or program that meets my budgetary needs. Any questions I asked were answered quickly and concisely. I can not say enough good things about the crew at MT Rarites. If you are looking for an excellent price, outstanding service, and flexible investing look no further."

Rating 10/10

"Best place to get your precious metals. If you don't know anything about silver, this is the place to go.I could. send my little old grandma and feel confident in the service Montana rarities provides."

Rating 10/10

"Just did a transaction with Mark. Very nice guy, and will gladly be doing future business with Montana Rarities. Found him during a website search for Engelhard Prospectors. Am quite pleased at the results of my dealings with him. You will be glad you when you choose Montana Rarities for your precious metal needs."

Rating 10/10

"There is not a better person than Mark to deal with. He is a 5 Star Seller and goes the extra mile for his customers. Thanks again Mark"

Rating 10/10

"I have done business here for almost a year now and I have to say I have yet to see any reason to look elsewhere. The proprietor (Mark) is direct, professional, and prompt with everything he does.
He is easy to work with and will always give you a level and honest response to whatever you inquire about.

Aside from the previously mentioned qualities, I really like the variety of products offered. He has the standard classics along with little known and seldom seen rarities that will make brief appearances before they are scooped up.

Also, he always advertises what he has in stock and I have yet to find him advertising something he does not have physical possession of (unless its noted in the description).


Rating 10/10

"Montana Rarities is the best online precious metals vendor I've delt with. Great pricing, FAST shipping and costomer service second to none. "

Rating 10/10

"Mr. Haythornthwaite was extremely responsive, and was very helpful in finding a solution to some difficulties I have in receiving shipments of valuable items."

Rating 10/10

"I was looking to sell some coins. I was nervous about dealing with a stranger over the internet, but being from a very rural area, the internet is my only option for a lot of things. I decided to take a chance with Montana Rarities because of the 100% positive reviews and I wasn't disappointed.

The entire transaction took eight days. I sent off my initial email inquiry on a Wednesday and received a cashier’s check on Thursday of the following week. Mark was professional, knowledgeable and the prices he offered were much higher that what I’d been expecting.

My only regret is that I don’t have more coins to sell, but if I ever do I will definitely deal with Montana Rarities again.

Rating 10/10

"My order was promptly shipped and the product was exactly as described and competitively priced. I will definitely order product from Montana Rarities again in the future."

Rating 10/10

"My order was easy to place, arrived quickly and was accurate."

Rating 10/10

"I have had two very pleasant transactions with Montana Rarities. The exchanges were both informative and profitable, so much so, that all my future transactions will begin with this vendor."

Rating 10/10

"Montana Rarities has been great for my silver needs! They are very professional, quick to respond to inquires, quick with their shipments and their prices are very fair! I am happy my Google search found their website. I look forward doing business again with Montana Rarities!

William E.

Rating 10/10

"Montararities shipped my order quickly and sent my silver discretely and well packaged.
Their prices are better than the big companies that deal with precious metals. I will definately buy again and recommend to family and friends.


Rating 10/10

"Montana Rarities is great! They worked with me closely and quickly to send over some silver coins (100 Peso 1977-1979 Mexico Silver 29.72). I foudn their website through a simple Google search, after struggeling to get my head around the highly-variable and confusing world of E-Bay! Boy, am I happy I ran into Montana Rarities! After a brief email, I heard back from a gentleman named Mark. He went above and beyond to make sure I could get my hands on these coins quickly,...even gave me a great price!

If you want an effecient process and a fair shake in getting the coins you're looking for, I'd recommend checking out these guys.

Learn about Our Reviews

Share Montana Rarities's store rating

Montana Rarities is not a merchant member. If you're this merchant, learn more!

Montana Rarities is not a merchant member
Montana Rarities does NOT participate at ResellerRatings to monitor feedback and resolve your issues. Are you this merchant? Learn more about the Merchant Member Program!

See all Merchant Members »