Elite seals are prestigious banners given to retailers who are loved by their customers. To get one, a retailer has to consistently get high scores over time
1 / 5 (1 reviews) average score over the past This merchant had 0% positive reviews over the last Six Months
Six Months
Positive: 0
Neutral: 0
Negative: 1
Write a Review
Customer Reviews | Filter Reviews
1/5
2024-12-21
Disappointing quality.
"Disappointing quality. The filets are average quality at best and do not compare to our local butcher or competing online choices. Expected excellence based on the cost. Exact same goes for their burgers, dogs and chicken. Will not order from Omaha Steaks again."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
1/5
2024-04-06
Sub par
"We ordered filets & steakburgers & paid 151.56. The filets had gristle in them, tough with little flavor. Burgers were dry with little flavor. We had received filets & burgers as a gift last year & was good. The meat we received when we ordered wasn’t up to quality we had received previously. When u pay 151.56 for meat you expect to receive good quality, we won’t be ordering from
Omaha Steaks again!"
Detailed Ratings
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
1/5
Updated on: 2024-01-23
Vegetarian Meal Package Not Even VEGETARIAN
"i got this as a gift from my boss who didn’t know i was vegetarian. So i was nervous until i found out there was a package called “the vegetarian meal” news flash- the first item, the pepperjack risotto cakes, have chicken stock and fat in the ingredients list. SOOOO misleading. disappointed, plus the potato au gratin made my stomach hurt. only good thing was the caramel apple tarts. if you’re going to make a vegetarian package, make sure it’s vegetarian!"
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
3/5
2024-01-05
Steaks
"We gifted the meat box to my son for xmas. He was not satisfied with the steaks in the box. At least the 2 he had a couple of days ago had a large piece of gristle going thru the middle of both steaks. Could not even eat them."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
1/5
2023-12-31
Terrible service
"Ordered steaks for Christmas for my family that is out of town I paid extra so they would be delivered on time and they arrived after Christmas and we’re warm so they sent another order and said they would be there on the 30th of December and they never arrived now they tell me they will be there on the 2nd of January so they will be bad also because it is in Arizona so my family never got there Christmas gift so don’t order from this company"
Detailed Ratings
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
1/5
2023-12-24
Failed Service, Failed Communication and the list could go on!
"I placed an order, I have an order #, I can not check my order status, it shows there is no payment history which there is intact one. I have a shipping date, I can not track anything, I can not tell the recipient their order is out somewhere in the atmosphere. It was a large order and I'm sure I was immediately charged. It's almost 2024, it should be easier, smoother, irritation free."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Dec-26-2023Oh no! Definitely not the experience we strive for. Can you please send us an email to custserv@omahasteaks.com with the Subject Line "Site Jabber" so we can look into this? We look forward to hearing from you.
1/5
2023-12-23
Never Again.
"I ordered Omaha Steaks as a Christmas gift to be delivered 12/30 as the recipient was traveling over Christmas. Without our approval this company changed the delivery date to 12/27. I was notified in an email of the change on 12/23. When I called to cancel, unbelievably, I was told I could not. The order has already shipped. Now it will be rotting in the mailroom for days. Merry Christmas. Home to rotten meat."
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Dec-26-2023Oh no! Definitely not the experience we strive for. Can you please send us an email to custserv@omahasteaks.com with the Subject Line "Site Jabber" so we can look into this? We look forward to hearing from you.
1/5
Updated on: 2023-12-18
Ordering by phone
"One of the WORST customer service experiences I've ever had!"
Detailed Ratings
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Dec-26-2023Oh no! Definitely not the experience we strive for. Can you please send us an email to custserv@omahasteaks.com with the Subject Line "Site Jabber" so we can look into this? We look forward to hearing from you.
1/5
2023-12-10
First time order and my last order
"NEVER received my order canceled and will never buy from Omaha Steaks again. They **** as a company!!"
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Dec-26-2023Oh no! Definitely not the experience we strive for. Can you please send us an email to custserv@omahasteaks.com with the Subject Line "Site Jabber" so we can look into this? We look forward to hearing from you.
3/5
2023-10-04
Pies
"The new cherry hand pies were not good at all. After trying four of the eight purchased (eight because I love cherries and the on-line pic was inviting), did not have one whole cherry in the filling and the crust was not very tasty and hard, should be a little bit flaky as a pie… never again!"
Detailed Ratings
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
1/5
2023-10-03
Botched order
"I have approximately $900 being held on my credit card for orders that do not exist. When I called customer service, I was told the first time to wait a day the next time that there were no orders so that couldn’t be. When I asked to speak to a supervisor, it was nothing but an argument. When the supervisor came on, he couldn’t explain why it was very nice and was going to place the order for me and after waiting for him to look for emails to find offers I just gave up. Love Omaha steaks, but it’s not worth it, my frustration level is ridiculous. Very disappointed with how the situation was handled."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Oct-03-2023Oh no! We’re sorry to hear you’ve had a bad experience; your 100% guaranteed satisfaction is our #1 priority. Can you please send us an email to custserv@omahasteaks.com with the Subject Line "Reseller Ratings" so we can make it right. We look forward to hearing from you.
5/5
2023-09-13
Absolutely the best there is !!
"I don't use the grocery store for meats anymore. The varieties, cuts, and quality that Omaha Steaks uses cannot be overlooked. Always arrives on time and solidly frozen."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Sep-13-2023Cue the happy dance! This is the feedback we live for. Thank you so much for the 5 star review. We are grateful for your business and loyalty.
4/5
2023-09-13
Beef and more
"There steaks are great espically the up grades. I would also like to say is there packaging is excellent as well as ordering and shipping. There are items I dont like but I try once and wont order again."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Sep-13-2023It’s support from customers like you that has kept up thriving for 105 years! Thank you for the 4 star review. We appreciate your business and loyalty.
4/5
2023-09-12
High Quality Filet But Overbearing Reminders
"I sent a deluxe gift of filet mignon to a family member. The quality of the beef was outstanding. Had to turn off the email reminders afterward however, I was often getting 4 or more emails per day. When I am ready to place my next order I will do so from your website."
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Sep-13-2023Happy to hear you were a fan of our filets! We make it easy and convenient to unsubscribe to our marketing emails! Just scroll to the bottom of an email from us and click on the “unsubscribe” link. Thank you for the 4 star review. We hope to see you soon!
3/5
2023-09-12
Decade long customer
"We love Omaha's products and have been repeat customers for over a decade. From Triple Trim Filets to fantastic Chilean Sea Bass, Mushroom Risotto and the list goes on. One disappointment with my last order. Sent Customer Service an email regarding a $30 reward card that I erroneously forgot to include the code. I immediately emailed after ordering requesting it be applied to that order, even including the order number. It was a time sensitive reward. I have not received any reply, nor phone call, nor was the reward applied. Very disappointed.
JW-54228"
Detailed Ratings
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Sep-12-2023Oh no! Definitely not the experience we strive for. So happy to hear you are a fan of our Triple Trim Filets, Chilean Sea Bass and Mushroom Risotto. You have great taste! Can you please email custserv@omahasteaks.com with the subject line "Reseller Ratings" so we can make this right? We look forward to hearing from you.
1 - 15 of 369 reviews
Read our Trust Guidelines
To learn more about reviews and trust on ResellerRatings.com, visit our trust page.
Help Report Fake Reviews
Notice something strange about a store's reviews? Let us know, or report the review directly.
About Omaha Steaks
Since 1917, Omaha Steaks has delivered the world’s best steak experience with absolute consistency from right here in America’s heartland. That’s not something we say lightly. As a fifth-generation family business, our passion and our reputation are built on customer trust and earned through experience, shared values, and the relentless pursuit of perfection. That means steaks that are hand-crafted by master butchers to make people happier. It means precise aging for tenderness, a culture of constant innovation and self-improvement, and the development of better foods and better logistics that allow us to guarantee perfection in every single bite, delivered perfectly to your doorstep every single time. Our customers trust us with dinner, with their families, with a gift for the most special of occasions. To gather around great food is tradition and love, and the Omaha Steaks mission is to deliver exceptional experiences that bring people together.
Retailer Information
Contact:
1-800-960-8400
custserv@omahasteaks.com
Omaha Steaks
visit the website
Share Omaha Steaks's Store Rating
0%
Reply Back Rate
This retailer does not reply back to reviews.
Collection Status
This company does not currently solicit reviews
Category Rank
Omaha Steaks is ranked #15 in food & drink
Omaha Steaks is ranked #3 in food
OmahaSteaksDJ from Omaha Steaks has responded
Posted Apr-11-2024