Compare Tire Rack vs SimpleTire.com

Compare prices, policies, and customer reviews of Tire Rack and SimpleTire.com



Overall Satisfaction

The overall satisfaction based on ResellerRatings algorithm that factors in recency of reviews. (Learn More).


44,675 reviews
4.59 / 5

1,284 reviews
3.88 / 5


Activity Rate

How recently the merchant has reached out to customers.

Tire Rack: recently active
SimpleTire.com: not active


Resolves Issues

Customers can change a negative review to positive after a helpful interaction with these merchants.

Tire Rack: yes
SimpleTire.com: no

Helpful Positive Reviews

Positive reviews found most helpful by ResellerRatings users

Tire Rack

5/5

2025-01-13

Cooper tires for Girlfriends Jetta

"I needed to get tires for my girlfriends Jetta and was able to shop for a tire that was affordable and that I felt would keep her safe. Able to put priority on things like wet and dry traction and not on snow traction since we live in FL. Tires arrived fast and on time. They ride super nice and she likes her car again. "

SimpleTire.com

4/5

2024-03-19

Easy website navigation

"Simple and smooth transaction, half of shipment was delayed,but only a day, otherwise great"


Helpful Critical Reviews

Critical reviews found most helpful by ResellerRatings users

Tire Rack

1/5

2025-01-15

Tire Rack was unable to fulfill order.

"Ordered my tires with the expectation date to only receive a call from tire rack that they were unable to fulfill my order. Extremely disappointing. "

SimpleTire.com

1/5

2024-09-11

Beware of Simpletire

"Beware of SimpleTire, they sold me a new set old4 year old tires and tried to tell me that this was an industry standard? Not honest company to deal with. After I contacted customer service I was told they would replace them and told they were not. Very poor customer service.
With Tire Rack they are honest and straightforward if they are selling you a tire that is of an early production they tell you. Never Again. Beware customer service will do nothing to make it right. They sent a reply as you can see below and after they contacted they did nothing.
"


Categories

See how each seller ranks within their respective category. Category rank is computed by comparing the aggregate rating of each merchant with more than 150 reviews.

Tire Rack is ranked #7 out of 191 in autos & vehicles

SimpleTire.com is ranked #63 out of 191 in autos & vehicles